top of page
Search

The Barbara O’Neill Phenom

Nov 3
7 min read

Her makeup-free, salt-and-pepper-framed, beneficent face graces unnumbered feeds. The followers on her Facebook and Instagram accounts, 1.8 million and 3.7 million respectively, keep climbing as she becomes a household name among the alternate medicine community. Is this global phenomenon a health genius saving lives, a rogue fanatic defying science, or a loveable grandmother giving advice to her kids? Whoever and whatever she is, Barbara O’Neill has rung a bell.


And become a lightning rod in the process. Hailing from Australia, she lives in a kind of exile due to a 2019 New South Wales Health Care Complaints Commission (HCCC) ruling permanently prohibiting her from providing services. (LINK)


In spite or perhaps because of the snub from the medical community, she has become a trusted source of health advice. Though lacking professional credentialing, her extensive knowledge of physiology and gift for conveying it with nothing but a white board and her pleasant, musical, prosody, has helped average Joes the world over understand the power of the body to heal itself, which she identifies as her core message. Using the “SUSTAIN ME” acronym, she cheerfully promotes the laws of health:


S- Sunshine

U- Use of Water

S- Sleep

T- Trust in God

A- Abstain

I- Inhale

N- Nutrition


M- Moderation

E- Exercise


I couldn’t agree more with that acronym. I live by it. Do you?


Abstain from Medicines?

The reason Barbara O’Neill has created such a stir is the expansion of the fifth principle-abstain. A typical health promoter will encourage abstinance of alcohol, smoking, and even caffeine, but Barbara goes beyond this, encouraging caution and even abstinence from things the medical industry regards as safe, including medications like antibiotics, and vaccines.


Medications

That I’ve found, Ms. O’Neill doesn’t disallow medicines completely, but issues strong warnings against them as causing secondary problems, such as fungal, mold, and yeast overgrowth, and antibiotic resistance. She’s not wrong. Medicines have side effects, and doctors prescribe these powerful substances too carelessly. The entirety of the Medical Industrial Complex is built around pills and procedures rather than prevention and health principles.


But in my observation, some people denouncing medicines underestimate the diseases that lead to their use. I have known several who died of the diseases they may have survived if they’d been willing to take a drug. It still boggles my mind that they thought dying was a better option than side effects. What’s a worse side effect than death? (LINK)


Vaccines

Barbara O’Neill reportedly promotes abstinence from all vaccines. The HCCC’s Statement of Decision lists the following as appearing in a lecture called “Child Nutrition.” I didn’t find that video anywhere, so perhaps she took it down. But given other messaging from Ms. O’Neill, I don’t doubt she said these things, perhaps at a time she wasn’t under as much scrutiny. For example, listen to this video and see if the anti-vax message is clear: (LINK)



Here are the statements listed in the HCCC’s report:

"The human body was designed to heal itself and does not need to be vaccinated." "Children can be naturally vaccinated against tetanus by drinking plenty of water, going to bed early, not eating junk food and running around the hills."

"The public is being lied to about vaccines."

"There are no safe vaccines."

"Vaccinations contain neurotoxins. Neurotoxins in vaccinations have caused an epidemic of ADHD, autism, epilepsy and cot death".

"Most doctors are not aware of the dangers of vaccines because they have not done the research.'

"Dr Andrew Wakefield's research indicated that MMR vaccine was linked to autism and published in the Lancet but later retracted because of a medical/pharmaceutical conspiracy."

“If you stop taking the flu shot, it will prevent you from getting Alzheimer's disease. (LINK)



I’m Not a Doctor but I Am a Thinker

Given my lack of medical training, I won’t try to resolve the vaccine debate. But I do want to weigh in on what I believe to be the historical, philosophical, and theological underpinnings of it. And those underpinnings have to do with our level of confidence in two things: the healing power of nature and the ingenuity of humans. My belief is that resistance to medical advances can be driven by an overconfidence in nature and an under confidence in God’s willingness to bless human genius.


For example, the smallpox vaccine. Englishman Edward Jenner developed the smallpox vaccine in 1796. By 1980, the vaccine had eradicated smallpox, which had killed 300 million people. Jenner, a Christian, wanted to save lives, and he did. He said, “I am not surprised that men are not grateful to me; but I wonder that they are not grateful to God for the good which He has made me the instrument of conveying to my fellow creatures.” (LINK)


Fast forward to today. The pure motives of Jenner and other pioneers have been overshadowed by Big Pharma. With money in the mix, vax companies contract with governments to push the vaccines on citizens. The number of recommended vaccines have multiplied to up to 72 vaccines given to children. Given that vaccines are not risk-free, this seems excessive. The industry has mingled the pure desire to save lives with greed.


But this corruption, and our resultant distrust of Big Pharma, can exist alongside judicious use of medical interventions. Ellen White said: “If the people would reason from cause to effect, and would follow the light which shines upon them, they would pursue a course which would insure health, and mortality would be far less.” (HHTL 179) The biology behind for example the smallpox vaccines harnessed this cause-to-effect response, enabling humans to develop immunity without contracting deadly diseases. Vaccines are preventative, versus just masking symptoms, so in that sense fall into the realm of functional medicine. According to firsthand sources, Ellen White herself received the smallpox vaccine and encouraged her workers to get it (LINK).


Medical interventions are biblical. For example, even in antiquity, God commanded circumcision. Foremost, the cutting away of penile foreskin served to symbolize the cutting away of filth from the heart, but secondarily it provided health benefits, especially in arid conditions where water was scarce and hygiene difficult. Circumcision was a medical intervention, complete with risks of infection and other risks. So were quarantine and isolation laws (Leveticus 13), and sanitation practices (Deut 23:12-13; Num 19). An “all natural” approach wouldn’t have cut the tender tissue of a newborn baby nor exiled women to avoid human contact during menses. God Himself commanded medical interventions.


My Personal Experience

While I stand in awe of the healing power of the body, certain life experiences have taught me its limitations. I share these stories because I know they’ve influenced my thinking. Take them for what they’re worth.


Due to my husband Michael’s post-traumatic arthritis (he fell through a roof on a mission trip), his bone-on-bone joint degeneration eventually robbed him of the ability to walk. His hip replacement about a year ago restored his ability to move again and probably gave him ten more years of quality life.


As I young adult I developed respiratory allergies which made me prone to secondary infections. If you shine a flashlight on the back of my throat, it looks like cobblestone. Bacteria lodge themselves in those cracks and cause me no small suffering. To treat raging sore throats, I repeatedly I tried every remedy, including fever baths to 105 degrees, golden seal nasal douches, enemas, colloidal silver, and fasting.


Understand that my temperament is to face obstacles vigorously. If a remedy requires effort, I’ll make it. But time and again, nothing touched the throat infections until I took an antibiotic. Bacterial infections differ from viruses, which are self-limiting. They can linger for months and years. Finally, Dr. Joseph Miller (RIP), convinced me that my chronic allergies made it necessary to go immediately on the meds at the first sign of infection. This would clear the infection in about one-third of the time it would take if I waited.


I hated that I couldn’t be exhibit A for natural remedies. My granola roots go deep; I’m an all-natural kind of girl. Everything within me rose up in protest to needing medicine. But the experience has sobered me, helping me avoid the dogmatism that sometimes drives the decisions of health-minded people.


A dear missionary friend of mine wanted to treat malaria naturally using all the right fever baths and herbs. It didn’t budge. His teammates, natural remedy types themselves, said, “Bob, take the medicine. We all did.” Bob finally took the least-potent antimalarial drug, which didn’t touch the parasite. The protocol would have moved him up the ladder to stronger drugs until he got to a one that would kill his particular strand of malaria. But having been conditioned to fear drugs, he believed the remaining symptoms were from the drug itself. Another friend approached him to say, “Bob, the malaria is affecting your mind.” Bob insisted he treat the disease naturally. He deteriorated until they rushed him to the hospital, where they hooked him up to a quinine I.V. But it was too late. Bob left this earth, his wife, his children, and his friends because he exaggerated the danger of medicines and minimized the danger of diseases. I miss him.


My dear grandmother died because of a version of this dogmatism. A Christian Scientist, she wouldn’t wear glasses, believing medical interventions to be a denial of faith. Visiting a store one day, this elderly lady asked to use the facilities. They were at the bottom of a dark staircase which a person with vision would have been able to navigate. Not Gramma Rae. The force of her fall was so great she yanked the railing right out of the wall. She never recovered from the traumatic brain injury and left us far too soon.


These are just a few of scores of firsthand and secondhand experiences that lead me to this: Yes, vaccines and medicines have risks. But in assessing the risks, let’s not trivialize the diseases they address. To do so is to disbelieve the biblical teaching that creation is under a curse. It is true that the body holds wondrous self-healing mechanisms, and we should use the SUSTAIN ME principles to encourage those mechanisms. But some diseases will kill us anyway. The earth, including our body, is fallen. Nature, designed by God to minister to our needs, can kill. God gives us wonderful immune systems, but He also gives us ingenuity to develop interventions that save us when our systems would fall short. Some of these medicines give us a fighting chance, friends. The black-and-white thinking driving some of us to refuse modern medical interventions could lead to unnecessary death.


And death has very bad side effects.


What are your thoughts? Comment below.

 
 
 

32 Comments


Guest
1 day ago

I wholeheartedly agree! A wonderfully written and well rounded article.

Like
Replying to

Thank you!

Like

Sheri Trueblood
4 days ago

I real wholeheartedly agree. I especially appreciated the point of God inspiring man with medical interventions. Its good to be reminded of that. I also appreciated the caution about being dogmatic. We, I need to be reminded of that too.


What has helped me navigate treatment and figuring out what God would have me do like when I got Malaria echos points in this post.


I intentionally try to live a healthy disease preventing lifestyle.


When I get sick I try to figure out the cause and address it.


I factor how time sensitive is the problem- as Dr. Jen mentioned natural remedies do take time.


I try to weigh up the risk/benfits if there is any side effects to…


Like
Guest
2 days ago
Replying to

Sheri Trueblood I feel such admiration and affection for you as I read what you say here. We’re both lovers of God’s healing methods but we’ve also been through some things that protect us from being righteous overmuch. :)

Like

Guest
Nov 05

I’d like to share a comment on Barbara O’neil’s post.

My 14 year old daughter had not been vaccinated since she was 3 years old. My 18 year old daughter is still being vaccinated to this day with all the preventives she needs.

My 14 year old has not gotten sick in years and she eats mostly junk food. I try feeding her healthy foods but she won’t have much of it.

My 18 year old gets sick from time to time but she has a problem with her period and every time she eats she has to use the restroom. She eats healthy for the most part and does not eat too much meat.

The different is noticeable. My…

Like

Guest
Nov 04

I'm thankful for this blog.

I've been dealing with 2 types of cancer for almost 3 years. I agonized over what treatment I should do. I talked to 2 people who help people naturally. I was hoping perhaps to incorporate both natural and conventional medicine. One person said they couldn't help me if I chose chemo because it went against what they believe. Another called it the devil's medicine. So I did the best I could with what I knew and with what was/is available. For a long time I struggled with my decision. I also wondered why some of the things suggested by Barbara O'Neill couldn't or didn't work for me. I have since come to the conclusion th…

Like
Guest
2 days ago
Replying to

Thrilled to hear this.

Like

Steve from Croatia
Nov 04

She used to be an Operating room nurse, which I think are the most badass kind of nurses, similar to Intensive Care nurses, which Ithink gives her a very interesting perspective on the limitations of main stream medicine. In my mind the surgeons are the most badass of doctors, and they work with OR nurses. So having a firm grasp of practical medical knowledge should make her a good filter for the crazier natural remedies stuff, and also a credible ex-insider critic. She is also a great lecturer. Now, I think grandmas how this tendency to be overly empathetic, and not telling people things how they are to soften the blow. It is understandable, but when you are dealing with…


Like
Replying to

Thanks for this, for filling in the gaps. Greed has taken over but there's still help to be found in allopathic medicine. I avoid when possible though.

Like
bottom of page