top of page
Search

Russell Brand, What Is Consent?

Oct 26
5 min read

Russell Brand, a celebrity actor and influencer, has been accused by six women. The trial started last week. From where I sit, things don’t look good for him. But I see in his situation and story some important principles of justice and the character of God.


The accusers have detailed allegations, which he denies, calling them a coordinated media attack. It does seem clear that the release of a documentary about him motivated the formal charges, as none of the accusers came forward during #MeToo, only filing reports after the documentary was released. (Details here) So these allegations could be opportunistic. The media outlet behind the documentary is on the other side of the political aisle from him. He did speak out against vaccines and perhaps formed political enemies who are now retaliating.


But the delay in reporting could also be a case of survivors finding the courage to speak up years after the abuse. And sometimes survivors find strength in numbers. Maybe the offer of being in a documentary gave them a platform and courage they didn’t have before.


What is Consent, Eh?

Several months ago, UK journalist Piers Morgan asked Brand how he could remember whether he violated people or not. Brand has gone on record as an addict. Maybe he browned out under the influence and did the unthinkable.


Brand’s answer was basically that the substance addictions ended before his promiscuity started.


I was a drug addict prior to becoming famous. . .The reason I wasn’t famous . . . was because I was an unviable economic proposition for potential media partners. . .I was never drinking or taking drugs . . .I was present . . .I have a good memory. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kv5tXkmEMyo)


But even if the charges of non-consent are wrong, the sticking point for me would still be the fact that he exploited women in ways that may not be illegal in the UK but are illegal elsewhere. For example, Brand admits a relationship with a 16-yeaer-old when he was 30. The age of consent laws in the states fall in different places: 32 states put it at 16, eight place it at 17, 12 set it at 18. This means that in the U.S. where Russell Brand now lives, he very well could have broken the law by having a relationship with a 16-year-old.


He admitted the profound power differential between himself, a celebrity with massive charisma and following, and a largely unknown teenage girl, calling it “exploitive.” (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFKgqE0p5rs) This, for me, is one of the core issues of this case.


Clergy and Consent

I did some research on how power imbalances in a religious setting impact the legality of consent. Texas penal code says that sex between clergy and congregant is nonconsensual, “if the actor is a clergyman who causes the other person to submit or participate by exploiting the other person’s emotional dependency on the clergyman in the clergyman’s professional character as spiritual advisor.” (https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/PE/htm/PE.22.htm ) Sex with congregants is also a crime in Arkansas and is criminalized in 11 more states and the District of Columbia if it occurs within a pastoral counseling relationship. (Cooper-White, P., 2012. The cry of Tamar: Violence against women and the church’s response, Fortress Press)


While power imbalance outside of the professions have not made it into criminal law yet, such survivors can sometimes win in a civil court if they can prove damages.


For these reasons I won’t be bothered, and neither should he, if he spends time in jail.


King David

Russell Brand has embraced Christianity over the past several years, undergoing baptism in the River Thames in April of 2024, shortly after first being approached by the police. Many will reject him as an imposter, assuming the Christian claim to be an effort to baptize his public image.


But my question is, what would we do then with King David? If anything, his crimes exceed Brand’s.


A little history: David spent years as a fugitive, chased down by King Saul and his militia. Even after Saul died, his son Ishbosheth attempted to retain royal power, waging a civil war against the incoming Davidic regime. Only after several years could David sit on his throne in peace.


But peace and prosperity betrayed the man, who lapsed into a spiritual lethargy. And one night his roving eye spied the bathing beauty Bathsheba from the palace roof. He ultimately impregnated her. Scholars debate whether he assaulted or seduced her, but in any case, he exercised his kingly power over her as a common woman, making what he did at the very least power abuse. He followed this crime with the devious, strategic murder of her husband.


Then a prophet showed up. Burdened with a call to issue King David a scathing rebuke, Nathan paid him a little visit. He told a story of a poor man with just one little lamb, and a rich man who snatched it. When David rose up in protest, Nathan pointed to David, crying “THOU ART THE MAN!”


It strikes me that Nathan’s parable didn’t include anything about the murder. Apparently taking the man’s wife was a greater crime than taking his life.


And Russel Brand, when he took the 16-year-old, wounded her in ways that could render future relationships very difficult. Every time one human takes sexual advantage of another, we rob them of something very sacred. And sometimes we take it permanently.


Thank God for Nathans. His confrontation of David, which could have cost him his life, led to the most powerful repentance ever witnessed. Read about it in Psalm 36 and 51.


And note that rich forgiveness did not erase consequences for sin. David’s child by Bathsheba died, and his life afterward was marred with turmoil. But I believe the most severe consequences fell upon his own psyche. He never regained his moral courage completely, leading to a certain passivity in the case of his son Amnon r@ping his daughter Tamar. This ultimately gave rise to the rebellion of Absalom and David’s temporary exile. Things were never the same for him.


And I think we’ll see that Russell Brand won’t just charge into his future in glory. There will be some kind of consequences. And personally, I think that’s right and good, even for him.


But, Salvation

But is there salvation for men who commit these sins? Yes. And that’s hard for some of us to get around.


Think about the person who did the most damage to you personally. Are you willing to accept God’s grace toward that person? Can you receive the reality that God loves them, that He’s working right now to bring them to deep, heart-searing repentance? And while not sparing earthly consequences, His Cross will shield them from eternal damnation, and take them at last to heaven for eternity?


Because that’s Christianity.


Leave your comments below.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page